What Do Japanese People Really Think of New York? A Thorough Look at the Gap Between Ideal and Reality

TOPIC

Supervisor: Naohiro Takemura

Started his career based on his experience at an accounting firm.
For approximately 30 years, he has been engaged in database marketing, finance, entrepreneurship, BPO operations, and new business planning.
He is well-versed in fundraising and financial management, and currently manages his own company while also undertaking outsourced work in management and new business development.

New York City is a dream destination filled with excitement for many Japanese people. However, the reality often differs from the idealized image, revealing surprising cultural differences. This article shares authentic impressions from Japanese visitors to help international readers better understand how New York is perceived in Japan.

Why Many Japanese People Admire New York

In Japan, New York represents freedom, success, and cultural prestige. It’s seen in movies, magazines, and social media as a place where dreams come true. Iconic landmarks like Times Square, the Statue of Liberty, and Central Park shape this image.

For young professionals and creatives especially, New York is viewed not just as a tourist spot, but as a personal goal. The city’s diversity is particularly appealing. Many Japanese people want to experience a society where individuality and multiculturalism are embraced—something that’s less emphasized in Japan’s more homogeneous culture.


Reality vs. Expectation: What Surprises Japanese Visitors

The reality of New York can feel jarring for first-time visitors from Japan. The crowded streets, noise, and fast pace of the city are often more intense than expected. Areas like Times Square can be overwhelming, and public transit—especially the subway—may seem outdated and confusing compared to Japan’s efficient systems.

Safety is another concern. While major tourist areas are relatively safe, Japanese visitors are often advised to be cautious at night, particularly in lesser-known neighborhoods. These differences don’t necessarily ruin the experience, but they do highlight the gap between media-driven expectations and urban realities.


Diverse Impressions: What Japanese Visitors Say

AspectPositive ImpressionsNegative Impressions
TransportationSubway coverage is extensive and usefulStations can be dirty and difficult to navigate
Food CultureInternational cuisine is easily accessiblePortions are too large; flavors may be heavy
HospitalityPeople are friendly and openService may feel cold or rushed
SafetyTourist areas feel relatively secureLocal advice warns of theft or unsafe areas
SceneryIconic sites are awe-inspiring in real lifeNoise, trash, and pollution can be shocking

This table shows that Japanese opinions on New York are nuanced, shaped by each person’s values and expectations.


Experiencing Cultural Differences Firsthand

One of the most meaningful parts of visiting New York is encountering cultural contrasts. Personal space, conversation volume, and public behavior all differ greatly from Japanese norms. In restaurants and shops, the lack of overly polite service or clear explanations can be disorienting.

However, these aren’t flaws—they are simply differences in culture. Understanding this helps travelers embrace the experience rather than resist it. Flexibility and respect on both sides make the journey more enriching.


Practical Tips for Japanese Visitors

CategorySuggested Preparation
AccommodationChoose a hotel in a safe, central area
DiningAsk about portion sizes before ordering
CommunicationLearn simple greetings and thank-yous in English
ShoppingExpect additional tax and tip on prices
EmergenciesKeep a note of embassy or hotel contacts for safety

These steps help Japanese travelers stay comfortable and confident, even when facing unfamiliar situations.


Popular Tourist Spots Among Japanese Travelers

DestinationReason for Popularity
Times SquareIconic, always vibrant and photogenic
Central ParkA peaceful green space in the heart of the city
The Met MuseumHouses world-famous art collections
BrooklynTrendy with art, coffee, and street culture
SoHoHub for fashion, shopping, and design

These locations offer more than sightseeing—they let visitors experience New York’s atmosphere at their own pace.


A Cultural Comparison: Japan vs. New York

TopicJapanNew York
Train SchedulesTrains run on timeDelays and schedule changes are common
Restaurant BillingPrices include tax; tipping is rareTax and tip are added separately
Public MannersQuiet and reserved behavior expectedLoud conversations and gestures are typical
Dining StyleDetailed and polite serviceSelf-directed, casual service is the norm
Personal SafetyGenerally safe everywhereVaries by neighborhood; awareness is essential

This comparison highlights practical differences that help set appropriate expectations.


Conclusion

For Japanese travelers, New York is more than a destination—it is a transformative experience. While it may differ from the romanticized image often seen in media, that contrast is what makes the journey meaningful.

By approaching New York with open-mindedness and curiosity, travelers can appreciate not just its tourist appeal, but the deeper cultural lessons it offers. That is why so many Japanese visitors return home saying, “I want to go again.”